Mad Professor's
HPLFF Review

Another year has come and gone, and with it it's crop of films at this years H.P. Lovecraft Film Festival. There were a couple I didn't get to see, simply due to the way the festival schedule was laid out, unfortunately. Here's my thoughts on this year's films (just my opinions, mind you):

Cast A Deadly Spell: I've always loved this, and it was good to see it on the big screen. Just excellent.

Forbidden Quest: The idea was nifty, to cut between the shots of the old man telling his story and old stock footage clips to back it up. It was cool to see all the bits of film they dug up to give the flick a sense of depth and story...but it was the weakest film at this year's festival, in my opinion. The sound work was uninspired, and at times was non-extant, making me wonder if the sound had a glitch or something. The repeated shifting from dark to mild shots to stark white icescapes hurt after a while. And there was no climax, it just went from boring to slow build to end credits. I felt completely gypped. Wish I'd skipped this completely.

Road To L: - Not the BIGGEST waste of two hours, but somewhere in the top ten, surely. An interesting premise, but a little too "Blair Witch" with very little pay-off. Lots of bad camera angles and angry arguments, building up to 10 seconds of garishly-coloured rubber mask.

Out Of Mind: Heyerdahl's portrayal of the old man is incredible, and it was just fun to watch. Good job.

Strange Aeons: The short last year never really grabbed me that much, but the full-length film this year was very well-done. Good performances, well put-together, and decent effects.

Dreams In The Witch House: I'm probably a little biased, being a huge Stuart Gordon fan, but I thought he did an excellent adaptation (especially considering he had to do it for a mainstream audience). Ezra Godden turned in a much less goofy performance than in 'Dagon'.

Dead Inside: Hooked me quickly by having a female lead that looked like Parker Posey and a male lead hat looked like a younger Bruce Willis, and kept me there was a pretty decent premise. Felt like a film written by gamers, and had a good 'quest' feel to it. Fairly well-done, even if the effects were a little cheesy...I can accept that in amateur films.

Arcane: Another film that felt like something was missing...like, you know, everything. "Here we are, here's what we're doing, and this guy sees something strange...and it's over!"

Lovecraft Syndrome: Just never grabbed me. Not bad, I guess, but I just never clicked with it. Eh.

Ryleh: interesting to see a full-3D rendered short, and decently done...but, dammit, learn to spell R'lyeh! (Spelled it right on the cover of the book, so why get it wrong on the film title?)

Late Bloomer: funny idea, and well done, but seeing the live performance of it was 20 times better.

Experiment 17: I'd have liked it more if it had been fleshed out and made into something, but as it was, it was too short and too hard to see. Was there and gone before I could really enjoy it.

King In Yellow: Yet another that felt like it was merely "chapter one" in stead of a completed short. The flash of the King in the chair was neat looking, the rest of it felt lacking. No real hook.

March 13th, 1941: John Strysik and I were talking last year about the fact that HPL is hard to film, so there are some stories that get made a LOT, just because they are easier to do. "The Statement of Randolph Carter" is one of them, since there is little to no actual creatures shown. Sadly, there isn't much else to show, either, which makes for boring cinema...like this one. A guy on a phone and a manhole cover.

Courtesy Nudge: Easily one of the most interesting of this year's crop. Funny, we-done, one of my faves.

Night of the Octopus: French movies don't usually strike me as impressive, but I have to agree with what I heard elsewhere; "best use of a dead octopus in a long time!"

It's The Great Cthulhu: Cute and funny, but the presents tossed in to frame at the end floored me. Nice follow up to last year's short about voting for Cthulhu.

ReCreation: Good film, for being so minimalist, and a good build off of a HPL story. I was annoyed at the crowd laughing at things that, frankly, weren't funny, but whatever, I don't like most humans anyway.

Statement of Randolph Carter: Oops, there it is again. At least this was built with some scenery, some build up, and some resolution. See, it CAN be done well.

Gibbering Horror of Edward Ghormley: another of my faves this year. Well shot, creepy...I kept waiting to see what was happening. The notes, the house, the man...all just perfect.

Antiques Roadshow: Arkham: laughed my ass off. Hilarious, and decently done. Nice to see people having fun with HPL.

Herbert West-Reanimator: this needed work. It wasn't bad, but it wasn't impressive, either. The constant blurring was annoying (maybe it was just a bad copy?), and having 99% of the film as just a narrator would have put me to sleep if the film hadn't ended. A little life injected into this one would have helped, ironically.

Read Me A Story: One of the tricks to a film short is that of back story. Too much, and the audience gets bored, expecting something that was going right to the meat; not enough, and an audience might feel cheated. 'Read Me A Story' could have used a little more back story, just to establish who and what we were looking at. This bugged me, but I also recognized that adding to what was there would have made the film drag. The emphasis was more on the shock of what happens, and that was delivered quite nicely without being obvious. The effects were well-rendered and the camera work and lighting brought the climax to full effect. Overall, a nicely-done bit of film.

Let Sleeping Gods Lie: just a trailer, but at least enough to make me curious to see the finished product next year. The method they've chosen to use could work well, or could get real old, real fast, so we'll just have to wait and see.

Call of Cthulhu: every year, there's at least one film that makes me very glad I went...this was definitely one of those. Even though the stop-motion Cthulhu was a tad goofy, it was beautifully done, and well worth owning. I was damn impressed, though there was one disappointment for me; in the trailer we saw last year and which was online, after the sailors looked up to find themselves face-to-tentacles with the Big C, there was a great shot of a silhouetted Cthulhu reaching a hand down to get them. In the finished film, this shot was replaced with the stop-motion Cthulhu, and it just didn't look anywhere near as cool. Oh well, it was still incredible.

Oh, and, lastly, Mad Martian's guitar-strumming bumpers were a riot.

Sadly, I missed "Beyond The Walls of Sleep", which I heard mixed reviews of from others, and "Marebito", which I heard was excellent. I wish I'd seen either of those instead of "Road To L." or "Forbidden Quest", that's for sure.

- Mad Professor

review © Mad Professor 2005

Home
| Email