The Statement of
Randolph Carter

Transformation: a new look at "The Statement of Randolph Carter"

"The Statement of Randolph Carter" is one of the most adapted short stories of H. P. Lovecraft. Although a variety of factors probably contribute to this, I think the most predominant one is that -- unlike much of Lovecraft's work (and the derivatives thereof) -- "The Statement of Randolph Carter", even in the heart of the narrative, doesn't show the monster. It's entirely the responsibility of the acting and the audience's imagination to create the terrible things that Harley Warren experiences beneath the grounds of that ancient cemetery. When Harley Warren reports that what he sees is monstrous and terrifying, it is only our imagination that creates that picture and, as any fan of the genre will gleefully report, our imaginations terrify us more completely than any image or sound ever

could. Our imaginations have the most direct access to every fear that has ever gripped us, to ever discomfort and distortion that has ever spent a few minutes teasing our frontal lobes. No force in the Universe has greater power to terrify us than our own imaginations and few of Lovecraft's stories so handily use that method to crawl under our skins as "The Statement of Randolph Carter".

The more I thought about this story and the more I thought about how I had seen it adapted, the more I saw what seemed to be peculiar holes. The relationship between Randolph Carter and Harley Warren is spelled out in some detail in the story, of course, but I never could quite grasp any sense of an emotional bond between the two of them. Why would Warren, knowing he was planning to leave Carter on the surface, bring the man along with him anyway? Why would Carter follow this man deep
into ancient woods?

As far as Carter himself, I had even more questions. In "The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath", Carter is an expert dreamer, a man of confidence and courage. Admittedly, he experiences fear and trepidation at times, but he does not balk at action. In fact, "The Dream-Quest of Unknown Kadath" is probably Lovecraft's most "action-packed" story, filled with journeys and battles and confrontations with gods. How could this man, I wondered, have evolved from the weak and frail man of Harley Warren's intimations? How could these two very different people be the same person -- a man too delicate of mental health to go into a tomb, yet willing to confront the gods and demand his Sunset City?

In a flash, a solution presented itself. Everyone -- no matter how skilled or gifted -- has to start somewhere. There must be a transformation from one form to another. If Randolph Carter is a powerful dreamer and space traveler for one set of stories, and a frail-minded liability in another, then there must have been a transformation, a place where Carter first tastes the strength within him, where he first makes a decision not out of fear, but out of grim necessity and responsibility.

That was what we needed.

"The Statement of Randolph Carter" is that nexus in Carter's life, where he is forced by circumstance to no longer be the frail

student, but must shoulder the responsibility of a master. This is where we enjoy a rare glimpse at the first spiritual growth spurt of the Universal power that Randolph Carter becomes.

Our movie evolved from that single idea. Yes, it had the elements of the original story to it, but it also had the connection I had missed originally, the sense of where and how this adventure sat in Randolph Carter's life, and where and how Harley Warren and Randolph Carter related.

Our crew is a subset of the crew that worked on our recent feature "Flesh of my Flesh". For many of them, "Flesh of my Flesh" was their first movie project and it was a big one, a live action horror/sci-fi/action project filled with stunts and practical effects. It was in many ways a crucible, and those who remained behind were left with a clear taste for more. Shortly after "Flesh of my Flesh" entered post-production, various members of the crew started looking for more projects and creating their own. "Flesh of my Flesh" had created many friendships and professional associations and people enjoyed following those threads even further. "Beer Goggles", "Buzz", and "Bugs & Beer" (the titles are only coincidentally similar, despite the semantic connections) are only three of the short projects that spun out from various sub-groupings of this talented crew. A passionate desire to make something special for the 2005 H. P. Lovecraft Film Festival continued chewing, however, so production started on "The Statement of Randolph Carter".

Aside from an appropriate location, probably the single most key element to the production was the tomb into which Harley Warren descends. The tomb was constructed off-site and transferred the day before shooting, undergoing a final surface finish once it was properly placed. In the story, a flat grave is used, but the location didn't allow digging (low water table), so we elected to use a raised tomb, such as the sort one might encounter in New Orleans or other locations. This turned out to be fortuitous because it allowed an actor to crawl completely inward, descending into the depths. Additional graveyard stones set the environment properly.

The location was tricky -- to find a place where a graveyard could be constructed, where we could film all night long, and where the Things of Man were not heard or seen. Through sheer coincidence (is there any, really, in these sorts of pursuits?), nearby construction had rendered a huge piece of property behind my house absent of light and mostly hidden behind a large wild-planted burm. For nearly 180 degrees, this allowed for filming with no man-made artifacts. It was a wild place and we had full control over it.

Casting happened quickly. Randolph Carter was played by veteran Lovecraftian actor/filmmaker Mike Shkolnik, aka "Mad Martian", who is not only a fine actor, but the curator of the Eyeball Museum (http://www.madmartian.com/eyes/) as well as other online atrocities. Shkolnik lent a calm believability to Randolph Carter. He was a man who was terrified, but who overcomes that terror and starts his growth into something better. Sean Strauss asked to be cast as Harley Warren, but in my mind the question was a formality -- I was planning to ask him anyway. Strauss is a professionally trained actor, and a newcomer to the front of Guerrilla Production's cameras, but earned his wings as an invaluable member of the "Flesh of my Flesh" crew, as well as being one of the movie's editors.
Strauss dove into the part of Harley Warren as a mentor to Randolph Carter, researching the original story as well as the script and making up anything else that needed to be.

The day of shooting started early for the crew, who had to complete construction and finishing of the graveyard and tomb. This was completed as the sun dropped slowly. We could not set lights until after dark, but the instant things went dark, we had to move fast because sixteen pages of script is very ambitious to shoot in a single evening. Dinner was served before dusk so all crew had a chance to eat, the cats were secured, electrical lines were pulled out and distributed, impromptu scaffolding was created, lights were hoisted and secured high on extension ladders. Before dark, our actors were dressed and their costumes "roughed up" by our makeup department. Additional makeup treatments gave the actors the look of two men who had been trekking through hard trails all day. Photos were taken, video shot of various setups, and shooting plans were finalized.

Electronics became a problem. First, a persistent buzzing in the sound turned out to be a bad microphone cable. This was replaced. We ran out of a large enough number of good headphones that not everyone who SHOULD have been monitoring sound COULD. Sometimes we switched around, other times, certain people went electronically deaf. Oddly enough, our boom holder had no headphones (this will be rectified in future productions, of course). Cables had to be replaced, connections had to be secured that were loose, etc. As with most amateur movies, everybody helped where they could, trying to get things working smoothly.

The first scene was slow going. Probably the most confounding factor was that everything was very dark and this made focusing and framing problematic. We tried a variety of methods until we had things working in a way that made sense. I think with most productions, that first scene is always a bit clunky anyway, while people figure out how they're going to fit together. By the time we hit the second scene, we were rolling along efficiently.

Still, as efficiently as we could shoot, the fact remained that we had sixteen pages of script to shoot and only so many hours of night remaining. Regularly during setup breaks, people were reminding us that it was getting later and later. Regularly we tried to keep the enthusiasm high. That night was a race from the get-go and dawn was fast approaching. We kept shooting, slicking production down even more. Now, the only thing that was causing trouble was the occasional goofed line and as everybody was getting more and more exhausted, this happened with greater frequency. Still, we kept pushing, kept at it. We had to get everything in the can that night.

One absurdly amusing moment during production: A tiny frog, half the size of a nickel, dropped on my head, bounced off, bounced off my shoulder, and landed on the copy of the script I was reading. In my sleep-deprived state, this became a moment of delight and I called attention to the wee beastie before eventually scooting it carefully from the bench and on into the bushes.

Finally, we're approaching the final scenes of the movie, the last moments. Dawn has started, the sky has lightened. Our DP and several of the crew all point out that the light is changing, that the video is looking significantly different. What to do, what to do...? Suddenly, I realize that we have been shooting in

sequence, shooting scenes in the order in which they occur in the story. I announce "Okay, here's the deal -- the last scenes of the movie take place during dawn. Let's keep going." This satisfies everybody and we keep shooting.

The very last scene is a brainstorm. In the script, the very last scene is a long shot of Carter, kneeling at the tomb. But in this case, we decide to put our DP INSIDE the tomb itself, cables snaking out. Framed perfectly by the walls and lid of the tomb, Randolph Carter swings his shovel. The bracing is knocked free and the tomb is resealed.

The time is about 6:45 am.

The next hour is a controlled and giddy chaos, as people move quickly to tear down all the lights and cameras and other electrical gear. Things are as put-away as they can be, the yard is cleaned up (although we leave the tomb and gravestones down for fun), cables are wrapped, hugs and fare-thee-wells are exchanged, and everybody goes home.

Now for the editing.

- Edward Martin III

The official Statement of Randolph Carter website can be found here.

article © Edward Martin III 2005

Home
| Email